March 1, 2008
A&W Float
The idea of a root beer float-flavored soda is a great one. But just how do you create the delicious ice cream and root beer flavors in a way that it can be bottled? Evidently, you can’t. A&W has tried with its new Float drink, but it tastes very little like a real root beer float. The components are all there – the root beer, the vanilla ice cream, the creaminess – but the flavor is overly sweet, heavy on the vanilla, and has an distinctly artificial aftertaste. It’s drinkable, and some may actually like it, but it’s no substitute for an actual root beer float. The shapely bottle would earn the Float extra points if Phoood gave points for packaging, but we don’t. At Phoood, it’s all about the flavor, which is exactly where the Float sinks.
Phoood rating: 
I have to disagree with you on this one. I saw this at Target and thought it was an awesome idea, so I jumped on it. I got the a&w flavor, and if it was good I was going to try the sunkist flavor. I ate dinner and had this to drink for dessert. I thought it was terrible. The vanilla flavor is wayyy too much. It tastes more like mixing an a&w with a vanilla cake icing. I gave my other three to people that were willing to give it a try and all three of them literally poured it out after their first few sips. It was a little sad watching my $5 going down the drain, but I couldn't get myself to finish it for them. My brother (one of the three who tried it) had a good idea that I never tried. He suggested that maybe if you dilute the vanilla flavor with a can of a&w rootbeer. I would give this drink a lower rating than what was given.
Posted by: danny d at March 3, 2008 11:33 AMThe bottle is cool looking. I'll assume it's glass?
Posted by: Jeremy Hobbs at March 4, 2008 10:19 AMI, my wife, our granddaughter, tried this one, but no one went back for a second sip. Likening it to a real root beer float is the product of someone's wildest dream. Sorry! It looked good in the grocery's display, but actual "taste" didn't agree.
Posted by: jerry leever at May 1, 2008 7:44 AMPlease keep your comments clean and relevant to the food! If your comment includes foul or obscene language, it will be deleted. Thanks!